AJ’s Grilled Cheese, Bay Shore NY | Merchant Profile

A family affair in the heart of Bay Shore, Ajís Grilled Cheese has brought an elevated fast casual experience, providing gourmet Grilled Cheeses to the area. Having only been around for six months, Ajís has set their mark on Bay Shore, gaining widespread notoriety for their newfound success. Owners Anthony and his son Anthony Jr. saw the need for something new and unique in the area, and with their carefully crafted sandwiches, have seen rapid popularity in their humble beginnings. The ingredients are fresh, and the customer can tailor their meal to their exact specifications, making Ajís Grilled Cheese a must while in the area. The options provide an infinite amount of variations to the standard Grilled Cheese, creating a new experience with each visit. With everything from Pulled Pork to Lobster, not only does Ajís raise the bar, they propel themselves to heights from what would normally be expected from the simple concept. The signature items are where the location really shines, mixing and matching different ingredients to adhere to different palates, doing saw flawlessly. The Buffalo or BBQ Chicken option is top notch, taking crispy chicken and topping it with their housemade BBQ or Buffalo, with Mozzarella, Pepper Jack, or American Cheese in between their fresh sourdough bread.The menu doesn’t stop there, offering fifteen different Grilled Cheese items in total, as well as the customization options. The Chicken Parm Melt comes highly regarded, crafted with Chicken, Melted Mozzarella, and their Creamy Tomato Sauce between their fresh Sourdough Bread. Although Grilled Cheese is their specialty, the vast array of soups and sides really bring everything full circle for the restaurant. The Mac and Cheese is just as popular as the Grilled Cheese, serving up choices like Thinly Sliced Sauteed Steak, Lobster, JalapeÒos, and Ham among many others. The location has most recently introduced beer on draft for customers to enjoy as wellThe food is great and the atmosphere matches the comfort style cuisine to the utmost authenticity. Upon walking in customers are treated as guests and the ambiance is nothing short of warm and welcoming. The staff are a family and seek to make each patron to feel as though they are apart of that family. Stopping in not only guarantees a satisfying, well portioned meal, but it also ensures a memorable, genuine time spent.  

182 W. Main St.
Bay Shore, NY 11706