American Cheese, Sayville NY | Merchant Profile

American Cheese is a unique eatery and shop that specializes in American cheeses located in Sayville, New York. Erin Nicosia and Christian Lennon are the owners of the shop who combined have over fifty years of experience in the restaurant business. Erin opened American Cheese with the desire to change peopleís perspective of what American cheese is. In addition to carrying common American cheeses that everyone knows, the shop also carries all kinds of exciting gourmet cheeses which are all produced in the United States. American Cheese first opened six years ago in a small shop on Main Street, but since the business has expanded and moved to its current location on Railroad Avenue where it has operated since 2013. American Cheese is your one-stop-shop for everything delicious. The business acts as a restaurant, bar, and cheese shop. They even offer catering services of all kinds, so be sure to check their website for full details. American Cheese has a warm and inviting atmosphere with a friendly, knowledgeable, and hardworking staff. If you ever have any questions or want some suggestions donít be afraid to ask the staff for help!The restaurant features an array of different tasty options to choose from. Their ìall-day menuî features different create-your-own cheese and meat plates that you can have as a snack or make into meal. The plates come with fresh bread and toasted nuts as well as additional accompaniments for an extra charge. All of their meats are smoked and dry cured in-house and come in an ìa la carteî style so you can pick and choose as much or as little as you want. American Cheeseís Fondue is also part of their all-day menu and comes in a Traditional Swiss Style or Creamy Oregonzola Blue. Fondue is served with fresh bread, housemade crostinis, and seasonal accompaniments such as apples, carrots, and potatoes.When it comes to lunch, American Cheese serves a variety of different soups, salads, sandwiches, and paninis. The Hawaiian is a popular lunch panini that is made with house-roasted pork tenderloin, grilled pineapple, Swiss, and sriracha aioli. For dinner, American Cheese offers an assortment of small plates that are always changing with the seasons. The Bacon Wrapped Dates and Triple Jerk Smoked Wings are some of customersí favorites. Be sure to save some room for one of their sinful housemade desserts. Theyíre always baked fresh daily so be sure to ask your waiter what they have available!In addition to their great food, American Cheese also features an awesome bar which focuses on domestic and American products as well. They carry wine and beer. All their wine is domestic and all their beer is craft and produced locally. The top of the bar is made out of an old bowling alley and itís the perfect spot to hangout, enjoy a drink, and a few small plates. American Cheese is even in the process of coming up with a special bar menu and wine & cheese pairings. After youíve enjoyed your fill, make sure to stop by their cheese shop to stock up on all your favorites to bring home! The shop sells cheeses, meats, and breads that are great for giving or keeping to yourself! All in all, American Cheese is the perfect place to dine, relax, or shop! The next time youíre in the area be sure to stop by for an experience youíll never forget!

289 Railroad Ave
Sayville, NY 11782