Rustic Tavern, Carlisle PA | Merchant Profile

Tom and Penny Petsinis welcome you to their restaurant the Rustic Tavern in Carlisle.  In the front of the house, Penny makes sure every diner is treated like family. Chef Tom is responsible for running the kitchen. Tom grew up in the restaurant business. He began working for his father at the age of about fourteen. Tom further honed his craft by choosing to work in other establishments, learning best practices of other chefs. The Rustic Tavern was voted the best Steaks and the best Crabcakes in Carlisle.The Crab Cakes and Prime Rib recipes are from Tomís father and havenít changed since 1976. All the beef used in at the Rustic Tavern is fresh and never frozen. Tom is able to track all of his American raised beef beef back its origin. This insures only the best quality meat is used. Fresh fish is delivered daily and Monday nights feature an all you can eat Crab Leg special. A popular lunch selection is the City Steak Salad. The Rustic Tossed Salad is topped with charred steak, potatoes, cheese, onions _and portobello mushrooms. The restaurant features a full bar with a variety of cocktail specials. There is a nice selection of wines both by the glass and bottle. The Rustic Tavern has seating for up to 180 people and can host private parties. Tom and Penny invite you to relax with friends and family by the fireplace or on the deck.Please come visit them today.

823 Newville Road
Carlisle, PA 17013